[Material Girl] Feet, the way God intended them
Vibram Five Fingers – Nature’s Best Shoes…
Since August I’ve been meaning to write a blog post about Vibram Five Fingers, these relatively new, innovative barefoot running shoes. I have literally had more than one revolutionary experience while wearing them. There are a bunch of new studies coming out that say barefoot running can significantly decrease the possibility for ankle, knee, and hip injuries. The basic premise behind it is that running without all of the cushioning, padding, and extraneous stuff that are often built into running shoes forces your foot to work the way God intended it to (or nature intended it if you’re not into the spiritual stuff). Our lower body is not designed to withstand constant heel strikes while running, which is exactly what traditional running shoes cause your feet to do. Barefoot running, in theory, will allow your feet to work in the completely opposite way, with the ball of the foot striking first and then rolling back to the heel acting as a shock absorber for the rest of your leg.
Some Links…
- Shoeless Joe from Outside.com
- To Run Better, Start by Ditching Your Nikes from Wired.com
- Foot strike patterns and collision forces in habitually barefoot versus shod runners from Nature Journal of Science paid access is required to read the full study
- Barefoot Running at Harvard
- In Running, Is Barefoot Best? from Harvard Magazine
- Daniel E. Lieberman, Professor of Human Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University
Coming from a background in Anthropology I can completely get behind Dr. Lieberman’s theories regarding barefoot running in correlation with human evolution. I just makes sense to me.
The Plunge
I was originally unconvinced that barefoot running could even be an option for me because I have incredibly flat feet. After having been to so many orthopedics and all of them insisting that orthodics were the way to correct my problem (none felt my flat feet or my pronation was bad enough to warrant expensive and painful corrective surgery), I had just given up. I’ve been buying shoes at exorbitant amounts of money that do not in any way shape or form meet the criteria of “cute” for a twenty-something-almost-thirty-year-old-woman. Comfort has been my only objective for the last 10 years.
On a whim I decided to try these Vibram Five Fingers. Actually, I decided after having seen a guy wearing them at our County fair and he didn’t get beaten up. I figured if he can walk around the County fair in these crazy looking shoes, then I should be able to wear them in public and not have too many problems. After a single day of wearing them around I was 100% sold! After a normal day of walking around I usually had pain that was probably 7 out of 10 radiating up my legs and into my lower back and hips. After wearing the Vibrams around I can honestly say that I had ZERO pain. At first I thought that maybe it was a fluke but after continual wear I noticed that my pain had been significantly reduced, if not totally eliminated.
But… that was not one of the two revolutionary moments that I experienced. That was merely an added bonus to make me not want to ship them back despite my DH calling me “Gorilla Feet.”
Revolutionary Vibram Moment #1
I’ve talked previously about flyball, that high-adreneline dog sport that DH and I play. My first Revolutionary Moment wearing my Vibrams came during a flyball tournament. I purchased my first pair (yes, I said first… and yes, I own multiple pairs) right before a flyball tournament this summer. I wanted to test them out at top speed.
I’ve mentioned what the dogs do during flyball, but I’ve never really talked about what the people do. It’s not just a sit back and watch the dog perform it’s “trick”; there’s quite a bit more movement involved. What the human does is quite a lot like running suicides. There’s a quick sprint up the lane after your dog (who runs it quite a bit faster than you do) and then upon reaching the start/finish line there’s a really fast pivot and you run back enticing your dog to chase you back down the lane. Depending on where you release your sprint could be 50+ feet or it could be less than that. The quick pivot has been known to bring down the most agile of flyball handlers, simply because you’re also usually dodging the dog that is coming back the same time you’re running up after your dog. It’s enough to throw just about anyone off balance.
That first flyball touranment I ran in my Vibrams was a life altering experience! The first “real” heat (because you rarely really run in warm-ups) of the first race of the day something miraculous happened. When I ran up and then pivoted to turn and run back my baby toe did something it has never been able to do before… it stabilized my pivot. I was turning on a dime and I felt every single one of my toes do exactly what they were intended to do. I couldn’t believe it! I was faster, more agile, more stable, and my feet were actually working for me. Suddenly I felt sorry for people that didn’t have all of their toes because all of mine were doing something to help me make that sharp pivot turn.
I have since tried to get Vibram Five Fingers to be our official club shoe. Sadly I have not convinced everyone.
Revolutionary Moment #2
Revolutionary Moment #2 came just the other night when I started my C25K program. Of course, I’ve done tons of reading that says that when you run in barefoot technology shoes that you naturally revert to the rolling motion that your foot should do, rather than striking on your heel. But I’ve been running (or trying to run since I’ve never really succeeded before) for nearly 30 years now. Heel-Toe is just the way it’s done, right?
Wrong.
Not in the Vibrams. Suddenly, I was running in a natural gait that felt wonderful. It wasn’t jarring, it didn’t feel like I was going to shake my head loose and my feet felt awesome! I truly never want to run in any other shoes ever again. Never never never again.
So… you want a pair now, don’t you?
There’s lots of places on the internet that carry Vibram Five Fingers. Among them, I’ve ordered pairs from REI and Kayak Shed. If you’re in the Washington, D.C. metro area and you want to try a pair ON, you can head over to downtown Frederick, MD to The Trail House. A woman in my yoga class purchased hers from there and was very pleased with her experience; I have yet to go up there but I plan to in the next couple of weeks.
A little note about the sizing. A lot of online sites try to “make” the Vibram Five Finger sizing fit to US or Euro sizes. And frankly, it just doesn’t translate. They use a modified version of the sizing based on how long your foot is, measured from heel to your longest toe. I highly recommend you checking out their sizing instructions on their site before you order a pair.
At the moment I own a pair of Classics, Sprints, and Peformas (which I kind of wish I had ordered in something other than black). To be quite honest, I’m not enamoured of the Classics. They have a drawstring elastic that runs through the shoe and tightens at the back on your Achilles tendon. To me, it pinches and digs in no matter how I adjust it. Just not comfortable. Surprisingly, I haven’t noticed the Performas doing this, even though they’re the same shoe basically, just in leather. But right now, my very favorite pair are my Sprints. They’re not a lot to look at, but they’re the most comfortable and I’m able to get the best fit because of the different velcro straps across the arch and at the heel. If I had to recommend a pair, I’d say get the Sprints. I’m hoping to get a pair of either KSOs or Flows to wear this summer when we go canoeing. But what I’d really love is for Vibrams to come out with a pair of KSO Treks for women.
I was very disappointed that their new line did not include a women’s version of that style. I’d love to wear them hiking because I like the idea of having the added balance with all your toes working for you, but I’m pretty sure that the soles of the regular Vibrams wouldn’t be enough to protect my feet from any pokey-outy (yes that’s a technical term) rocks that might be on the trail. I’m hoping that they’ll see how great they are and then put out a women’s version of the Treks soon!
I have not been compensated, nor will be, in any way by Vibrams or their affiliates. I was not instructed to review this product in a postive light. All observations are my own. I am not an affiliate of the Vibram company and do not receive any compensation for click-through links contained in this specific post.














I’ve been interested in these shoes ever since I first heard of them – and I really, really want to try a pair now! I wonder if REI sells them in-store. Would be nice to be able to try on …
Where are you running in them? Curious if you’re on a treadmill or outside – if you step on a rock or anything odd on the road, is there enough cushioning to keep it from hurting?
Thanks for the awesome review!
Melissa´s last blog ..Hope for the best, expect the news crews
The REI where we live don’t sell them in-store. But when you come up to DC you can come out to Frederick! We could meet for dinner!!
I am running on a treadmill right now. I’ve worn them (walking, not running) on gravel before. As long as the gravel isn’t too big it hasn’t bothered me. The soles are more substantial than they look. They are the regular Vibram rubber that are on hiking boots. Our driveway is gravel and I’ve jogged across it to get the mail and not bruised my feet.
Nice Vibram round-up! I don’t know if you’ll catch my tweet (or understand it), but I try and track all VFF reviews on a weekly basis (I put out a weekly list on Sundays). Seems I missed yours for this week, but I’ll definitely pick it up for next.
That said, I want to let you know that Vibram will be releasing KSO Trek Five Fingers for women! Seems they heard the people and realized that there was indeed a demand for women’s KSO Treks — release date is late Spring the last I heard.
Also, I’m curious if you are wearing your Classics “loose” with zero cinching of the drawstring. I ask because in my experience, the Classics shine when you wear them more like a sandal, only tightening up the strap if you find yourself suddenly sprinting or doing some sort of jerky motion. It’s in this context that I’ve deemed Classic FiveFingers my favorite VFFs for all-around wear. Though I think Sprints are great in many applications, I think dialing in the three strap method is tricky enough to frustrate most. I had to stick with my Sprints for a few weeks before I got the straps just right. Now I’m good to go, but I was banging my head on the table for awhile trying to get the fit right.
For what it’s worth, you’re one of the few people I’ve seen who actually has the Performa. I’m curious: what are you using yours for? Though I’ve gotten a ton of user VFF stories, I’ve only had *one* Performa story submission so far. Seems Performas are somewhat rare in the VFF world.
Anyway, like I said, will pick up this review *next* Sunday and apologize for not grabbing it already.
justin´s last blog ..More 2010 and 2011 updates from Vibram: New versions of the FiveFingers Sprint and KSO Trek Proposed use different materials for the upper
Thanks!! Right before I got your comment on my post I was sitting in The Trail House and the woman there told me the good news about the KSO Trek for women! I just hope that it comes in time for my potential hiking trip in Italy (we haven’t decided on an itinerary and our trip may or may not involve hiking)!!
I’ve tried wearing the Classics loose, tight, every way possible. The pinching is only on one foot (my right). I think’s my larger foot, so it might be that the size is just a tad too small. I think that this is all very strange because the Performas don’t bother that foot at all. *shrug* I’ll go back and try loosening the Classics again and see what happens.
As for the Performas, at the moment I’m only wearing them around the house and at work. Like some of the “commuter” people who wear tennis shoes to work and then put on their dress shoes, I’ve been wearing snow boots (because I live in Northern VA – and this is the snowpocalypse) to work and then changing into the Performas when I get there. I’m contemplating trying them out for yoga, but I’m not sure what my yoga teacher will say about that… she’s pretty particular about shoes in the “studio area” (I think that it’s considered rude in the culture).
Thanks for the blog shout out! I’m hoping to pick up a pair of Bikilas just as soon as I can get my hands on a pair and I’ll review them here as well. Maybe I’ll do a little review of the Performas when I figure out what to do with them… I just love how soft they are. They live in my purse, I take them everywhere so I can always be comfy!
Maybe you should just cut the Classics strap out — it’s a permanent solution, but it might be the way to go for you.
I’ll be posting hands on info on the Bikila just as soon as I get a pair, which hopefully will be just as soon as they start hitting the streets, so keep an eye out!
justin´s last blog ..More 2010 and 2011 updates from Vibram: New versions of the FiveFingers Sprint and KSO Trek Proposed use different materials for the upper